The title page reads "CHAPTER 689: AN ISLAND THAT SEEMS NOT TO EXIST." The cover story continues with "CARIBOU'S KEHIHIHIHI IN THE NEW WORLD - VOLUME 14 - JUST BARELY MADE IT TO AN ISLAND SOMEWHERE." The illustration shows Caribou's side story rather than the main Punk Hazard action: Caribou has washed up on a strange snowy-looking island scene after barely escaping. This page is useful because it confirms the chapter title and the Caribou cover-story installment, but it is separate from Caesar's broadcast and Luffy's confrontation with him.
Caribou
01
In R-Block, second floor, the secret room, Caesar broadcasts to the soldiers of Punk Hazard. He addresses them directly: "SOLDIERS OF PUNK HAZARD!! YOU'VE ALL BEEN FOOLED!!" The crowd below watches screens showing different parts of the lab, and one man asks, "IT'S BROWN-BEARD!! WHAT'S HE TALKING ABOUT?" Caesar declares, "EVERYTHING CAESAR HAS SAID IS A LIE!!" and then threatens them: "IF YOU STAY HERE, YOU'LL ALL BE KILLED!! YOU'RE WATCHING ME FROM SOMEWHERE RIGHT NOW, YEAH!?" On the first floor of R-Block, Brownbeard explains to his men, "BROWN-BEARD IS RIGHT BELOW US DOWN ON THE FIRST FLOOR OF R-BLOCK!!" Someone asks if they should call him up, but Brownbeard says, "...NO. I'M HEADING DOWN THERE." He insists, "I HAVE TO REVEAL TO YOU CAESAR'S TRUE INTENTIONS!!" The page begins the chapter's central betrayal: Caesar's own followers are about to learn that their savior has been using them.
Caesar ClownBrownbeardCaesar Clown's Subordinates
02
At R-Block's first floor, in front of the R-66 gate, Brownbeard reaches the sealed entrance while a monitor and intercom chatter nearby. He yells, "CAESAR!!" Caesar answers coldly through the screen, "WHAT'S THE BIG IDEA HERE, MY MOST EXCELLENT SUBORDINATE, BROWN-BEARD!! YOU'RE BEING QUITE INSISTENT!!" Brownbeard demands, "GIVE ME BACK MY MEN!! WE WERE ROBBED BACK THERE, IN THE MIDDLE OF THE ISLAND, BUT..." Caesar brushes him off: "IT'S NOT AS IF THEY DIED!! THEY SHOULD HAVE COME BACK A WHILE AGO!!" The page shows Brownbeard standing wounded but furious before the massive R-66 door. He is no longer acting like a loyal underling begging for orders; he has come to confront the master who abandoned his people.
BrownbeardCaesar ClownCaesar Clown's Subordinates
03
Brownbeard's men report that they cannot get inside. One says, "MASTER--!! THE FRONT ENTRANCE IS SWARMING WITH MARINES AND THE GATE IS CLOSED..." Another adds, "HAA... HAA... WE CAN'T GET INSIDE!! TELL US WHAT WE SHOULD DO...!!" Caesar mutters, "WHAT'S WRONG? ...OH, BROWNBEARD'S MEN?" and then dismisses them entirely. When asked, "MASTER, HOW ARE YOU GOING TO GET THEM INSIDE?" Caesar says, "FORGET ABOUT THEM. THE ISLAND IS GOING TO BE COVERED WITH SHINOKUNI BEFORE LONG, ANYWAY." The words devastate Brownbeard. Caesar continues with casual indifference: "GOOD GRACIOUS, I WONDER WHAT COULD BE WRONG. I HAVEN'T HEARD FROM THEM. ACTUALLY, I WAS ALSO JUST STARTING TO WORRY...!!" The page exposes Caesar's cruelty in real time. His subordinates are pleading for help, and he treats their deaths as an inconvenience already accounted for.
Caesar ClownBrownbeardCaesar Clown's Subordinates
04
Brownbeard sees the truth and begins warning the others. He says, "IF... THEY HAVEN'T COME BACK ALREADY... AND THEY'RE STILL OUTSIDE... THEN..." and then, shaken by what Caesar has done, "I CAN'T TRUST ANYTHING YOU SAY ANYMORE!!! HOW COULD HE SAY SUCH A THING TO MASTER!?" Someone asks, "BROWNBEARD, WHAT THE HELL HAPPENED TO YOU!!" Brownbeard turns to his fellow subordinates and shouts, "YOU GUYS TOO! WE'VE SPENT TWO GOOD YEARS ON THIS ISLAND TOGETHER!! BUT WE'VE GOT TO LEAVE IMMEDIATELY! WANT TO KNOW WHAT THIS GUY HAS BEEN CALLING YOU BEHIND YOUR BACKS!?" Caesar has called them "HINNEY FIGS!!" "FINNEY TIGS!!" and, most clearly, "GUINEA PIGS!!" Brownbeard finally understands the insult beneath Caesar's affection. The men who worshiped Caesar as a savior were test subjects to him.
BrownbeardCaesar ClownCaesar Clown's Subordinates
05
The soldiers laugh because they do not understand Brownbeard's slurred words. They shout, "DAHAHA HAHAHAHA!! WHAT ARE YOU SAYING, BROWNBEARD!!!" "SPEAK CLEARLY!!" and "WHAT SORT OF INCAN-TATION ARE YOU TRYING TO SAY!!" Brownbeard tries again, "PINNEY... GIGS!!" and someone mocks, "MIGS--" while another asks, "WHAT THE-- MY MOUTH WON'T MOVE WHY--!?" Brownbeard realizes the problem: "THEY'RE ALL IDIOTS, SO THEY HAVEN'T REALIZED!! THEY DON'T KNOW THAT HE'S JUST TRYING TO SAY 'GUINEA PIGS'!!" Caesar has secretly drugged him too, explaining, "IT'S A MUSCLE RELAXANT. YOU CAN FEEL THE POWER SLIPPING AWAY FROM YOUR MOUTH AS WELL AS YOUR WHOLE BODY, RIGHT? SHURORORORO." Brownbeard collapses toward Caesar's dragon-like form as the crowd continues laughing. Caesar is not only lying to his men; he is physically silencing the one subordinate trying to warn them.
BrownbeardCaesar ClownCaesar Clown's Subordinates
06
Caesar twists the betrayal even further. He says, "OH, THAT'S RIGHT... I JUST REMEMBERED, BROWNBEARD... ABOUT YOUR FORMER UNDERLINGS... I ABANDONED THEM!" Brownbeard, barely able to speak, howls, "YOU!!! YOU ROTTEN BASTARD... HOW DARE YOU... MY MEN!!" Caesar laughs in front of the watching soldiers and adds another confession: "AND WHILE WE'RE AT IT... THERE'S ONE MORE THING. FOUR YEARS AGO, THE WEAPON OF MASS DESTRUCTION THAT BROUGHT ALL THE SOLDIERS HERE TO THE BRINK OF DEATH..." Then he says it plainly: "THAT WAS MY DOING." Brownbeard realizes the scale of the lie and screams, "SO IT WASN'T VEGAPUNK...!? YOU... YOU'RE THE ONE WHO DID THAT TO THEM!! BUT YOU PRETEND TO HAVE SAVED THEM...!?" The page reveals the foundation of Caesar's cult. He poisoned the island, blamed Vegapunk, then posed as the savior of the victims he created.
Caesar ClownBrownbeardVegapunkCaesar Clown's Subordinates
07
Brownbeard snaps. He surges forward despite the relaxant, screaming, "UUUU OOOHH HAA!!!" and the soldiers panic: "HEY, WHAT ARE YOU DOING, BROWN-BEARD!!" "SOMEONE HELP ME!!" "OI!!! BROWN-BEARD!!!" They cannot understand why he is attacking the man they call their savior. Brownbeard bellows, "UAARUROOO OOOOOOO!!! BUOOOHH!!!" and warns them, "THIS ISLAND IS A LIVING HELL, ORCHESTRATED FROM START TO FINISH BY CAESAR!!! RUN, YOU GUYS!!" Others shout, "WHAT ARE YOU DOING TO OUR GREAT SAVIOR...!!" and "HE'S A DEMON MASQUERADING AS A MAN!!" while someone cries, "RUN AWAY, EVERYONE!!" The page becomes a revolt born too late. Brownbeard is trying to save men who still do not know whether to fear Caesar or him.
BrownbeardCaesar ClownCaesar Clown's Subordinates
08
Caesar turns the room against Brownbeard by twisting the story for the soldiers. Someone cries, "OH NO!!! BROWNBEARD HAS BECOME QUITE DANGEROUS!!!" and Caesar says, "WE MUST BE TOO LATE... IT LOOKS LIKE HE'S SOMEHOW BEING MANIPULATED BY STRAWHAT!!" The soldiers shout, "FIRE!!" and open fire as Brownbeard charges on his reptilian mount. Caesar smiles and says, "SHURORORORO!! AND NOW FOR THE FINISHER." He flicks something and prepares a gas attack while the soldiers still believe he is protecting them. The page shows how easily Caesar weaponizes their loyalty. Brownbeard is telling the truth, but Caesar's authority turns him into the villain in their eyes before he can save them.
Caesar ClownBrownbeardCaesar Clown's SubordinatesMonkey D. Luffy
09
Caesar unleashes "GASTA..." and a violent gas explosion erupts across the room. Brownbeard is struck amid the blast, and soldiers scream "MASTER!?" and "GYAH HH!!" One cries, "DAHHH!! TH-THAT WAS CLOSE!!" while another says, "IT GRAZED ME!!! SHIT, WHO'S THIS NOW!!" The blast is enormous, black and white gas filling the double spread as Caesar's attack catches Brownbeard and nearly hits his own men. At the edge of the chaos, Luffy appears. He looks grim and furious, telling Caesar, "I'VE BEEN PICKING THOSE SORTS OF FIGHTS THE WHOLE DAMN WAY!!" The page pivots from Brownbeard's failed charge to Luffy's arrival. Caesar's broadcast has exposed the truth, and now the person who actually can hit him has reached the battlefield.
Caesar ClownBrownbeardMonkey D. LuffyCaesar Clown's Subordinates
10
Luffy steps through the smoke, and the soldiers recognize him: "IT'S STRAWHAT LUFFY!!" Brownbeard lies badly hurt nearby, still clinging to the belief that Caesar once saved them. A subordinate says, "OUR LIVES WERE SAVED THANKS TO MASTER'S KINDNESS," and another insists, "MASTER IS OUR MERCIFUL SAVIOR GOD...!!" Luffy's face remains hard as he listens. Around him, Brownbeard groans, "AULU... AULU..." while the crowd hesitates between what they have heard and what they were taught to believe. The page is quiet compared to the explosion before it. Luffy has arrived at the moral center of the conflict, where Caesar's followers still cannot fully accept that their savior is the monster.
Monkey D. LuffyBrownbeardCaesar ClownCaesar Clown's Subordinates
11
Caesar tries to return to business as if nothing matters. He orders, "NNNN!!! GET BACK TO THE SECOND FLOOR, MEN!!!" and says, "THE REST OF HIS CREW AND THE MARINES WILL START APPEARING ONE AFTER THE OTHER ANY MINUTE NOW. PREPARE FOR THE EXPERIMENT TO COMMENCE!! AND CONNECT THE BROAD-CASTER TO EVERY REGION POSSIBLE!!" Luffy stands nearby with Momonosuke, and someone calls, "LUFFY." Momonosuke listens as Caesar speaks of the children: "SO YOU'RE MOMONOSUKE-KUN, HUH. YOU HAVE TO EAT, YOU KNOW... TO SUCH KIND-HEARTED YOUNGSTERS, HE WOULD...!!" Caesar then laughs about the future: "FIVE YEARS FROM NOW NOT ONE WILL BE LEFT ALIVE!! SHURORORORO." Luffy says only, "I KNOW..." The page connects what Luffy heard from Momonosuke with Caesar's own mouth. The children's deaths are not rumor anymore; Caesar is confirming them in front of Luffy.
Caesar ClownMonkey D. LuffyMomonosukeCaesar Clown's ChildrenCaesar Clown's SubordinatesMarines
12
Luffy says that everyone on Punk Hazard has been deceived: "...EVERYONE HERE HAS BEEN TRICKED IN SOME WAY." Caesar answers, "SHURORORORO... THAT'S RIGHT. HAA... HAA..." Luffy looks around and asks, "WHAT THE HELL KIND OF ISLAND IS THIS!!" Caesar explains with pride rather than shame: "...IT'S REALLY A LOT LIKE 'GAS.' AN ISLAND THAT DOESN'T SEEM TO EXIST!!" He reveals why Punk Hazard is useful to him: "AND IT'S FOR THAT REASON THAT I CAN BUILD SUCH STRONG CONNECTIONS WITH THE UNDERWORLD!! THIS PLACE IS A PERFECT BASE FOR SCIENCE DONE IN THE SHADOWS!! UNFORGIVABLE EXPERIMENTS. AND THE ESSENTIAL SUPPLY OF BODIES FOR TESTING!!! I'VE GOT EVERYTHING I COULD POSSIBLY WANT!!" The page defines Punk Hazard as a hidden criminal laboratory: invisible to the world, perfect for illegal experiments, and full of people Caesar can use.
Monkey D. LuffyCaesar Clown
13
Caesar says that in the end, everything is covered up: "AND IN THE END, IT'S ALL COVERED-UP THANKS TO A POWERFUL ALLY WHO'S GOT MY BACK!! IT'S LIKE NONE OF IT EVER HAPPENED!!" The image behind him points to Vergo and Donquixote Doflamingo, making clear the protection behind Caesar's operation. Caesar taunts Luffy: "YOU CAN CRY... YOU CAN SCREAM...!! BUT NO ONE WILL COME TO SAVE YOU!!" He continues, "WHAT A SHAME THAT YOU HAVE TO DIE NOW, FOR HALF-ASSEDLY STICKING YOUR NOSE WHERE IT DIDN'T BELONG!!" Brownbeard lies broken nearby while Caesar tells Luffy, "YOU DON'T KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT THIS ISLAND!! STRAWHAT!!" He adds that Law is trying to steal the S.A.D.: "LAW IS TRYING TO GET HIS HANDS ON THE S.A.D.!! I'M THE ONLY ONE WHO CAN PRODUCE IT!! SO HE'S PLOTTING TO KIDNAP ME AS WELL!!" and says, "SAME GOES FOR THAT 'ALLIANCE'!!" The page lays out Caesar's confidence: secrecy, Doflamingo's backing, S.A.D., and the belief that Luffy has stepped into a world too large for him.
Caesar ClownMonkey D. LuffyBrownbeardTrafalgar LawVergoDonquixote Doflamingo
14
Caesar reveals the greater underworld structure behind S.A.D. He says, "THAT SHICHIBUKAI... HE, THE MOST DANGEROUS MAN OUT THERE...!! DONQUIXOTE DOFLAMINGO HAS A FACTORY THAT TURNS S.A.D. INTO FRUITS CALLED 'SMILE'...!!" He explains that "SMILES" are, in fact, "MANMADE DEVIL FRUITS HOLDING ZOAN POWERS WITHIN...!!" and calls them "FRUITS SOUGHT AFTER BY ANYONE CRAVING POWER...!!" Using SMILE, Doflamingo "DOES BUSINESS WITH THE BIG NAMES OF THE NEW WORLD." The imagery shows an artificial fruit surrounded by beastly fighters, emphasizing the scale of what Caesar is enabling. This page is a major world-building reveal: Caesar's S.A.D. is the raw material for artificial Zoan Devil Fruits, and Doflamingo sells those powers into the New World.
Caesar ClownDonquixote Doflamingo
15
Caesar explains the threat that SMILE has already created. He says, "I'VE HEARD THAT, THANKS TO SMILE, ONE OF THE YONKOU HAS ALREADY AMASSED AN 'ABILITY USER CORPS' OF SEVERAL HUNDRED MEMBERS...!! IT CHILLS MY BLOOD TO IMAGINE...!!" Then he warns Luffy to understand the scale: "CAN YOU GRASP THE SCOPE OF WHAT I'M SPEAKING OF!? INTERFERE WITH DOFLAMINGO'S BUSINESS DEALINGS AND YOU'LL INCUR THE UNIMAGINABLE WRATH OF THE BIGGEST PLAYERS OUT THERE!!" Caesar mocks the idea of challenging them: "WHEN THOSE BIG NAMES START TO MOVE... THE WHOLE WORLD WILL RESPOND IN TURN!! LAW IS AIMING FOR JUST THAT. WHAT AN IDIOT!! YOU FOOLS ARE YET A COUPLE OF PITIFUL FLEDGLINGS!!" He laughs, "SHURORORO JUST TRY AND CATCH ME...!! I'M WELL-PROTECTED...!! 'DOFLAMINGO'!! A 'YONKOU'!! DO YOU REALLY HAVE THE STONES TO PICK A FIGHT WITH SUCH PLAYERS!?" Luffy listens silently, but the page makes clear that striking Caesar means stepping into a conflict with Doflamingo and an Emperor.
Caesar ClownMonkey D. LuffyTrafalgar LawDonquixote DoflamingoYonko
16
Caesar's speech ends when Luffy answers with his fist. Luffy, furious, launches himself forward and slams into Caesar with a huge impact. Caesar had asked whether Luffy had the nerve to pick such fights, and Luffy replies through the attack: "I'VE BEEN PICKING THOSE SORTS OF FIGHTS THE WHOLE DAMN WAY!!" The strike crashes across the double spread, catching Caesar mid-boast and hurling him back. Brownbeard and the soldiers watch in shock as Luffy's punch cuts through Caesar's entire argument about Doflamingo, the Yonko, and the underworld. The page closes the chapter with a decisive rejection of intimidation. Caesar believes alliances and hidden power make him untouchable; Luffy treats those threats as exactly the kind of fight he has always chosen.
Monkey D. LuffyCaesar ClownBrownbeardCaesar Clown's SubordinatesDonquixote DoflamingoYonko
17
No description for this page.
End of chapter18 pages
Discussion
p8A switch is activated during Brownbeard's rampage.
p9Brownbeard's tail strikes marines during rampage.
p9Marines are injured but survive the tail attack.
p10Luffy arrives in the ruined corridor.
p10Marines credit their survival to master's kindness.
p10Luffy maintains a serious expression upon arrival.
p11Experiment preparation is ordered in the facility.
p11Momonosuke interacts with a horned figure and a young girl.
p11Luffy is mentioned as approaching the area.
p12Luffy and Law enter a dark metallic chamber.
p12The chamber door is labeled OPEN.
p12The scene transitions to a barren rocky landscape with white figures.
p13Law explains his alliance and the cover-up of events.
p13Chaos occurs inside a facility with masked and armed combatants.
p13A samurai-like figure and pigtail girl appear in the facility scene.
p14Doflamingo operates a factory producing SMILE fruits from S.A.D.
p14SMILE fruits are manmade devil fruits containing Zoan powers.
p14Hordes of ability users and beasts are amassed around a giant fruit.
p15Doflamingo has amassed several hundred ability users via SMILE.
p15Interfering with Doflamingo's business risks wrath from major players including a Yonkou.
p15Luffy stands before a massive beast in the facility area.
p16Luffy lands a devastating punch on the spiky-haired opponent.
p16The page depicts a high-impact strike with major visual effects in chapter 689.
What is said, page by page
p0Narration box introduces Caribou's volume 14 entry about barely reaching an unknown island, setting isolated survival mood.
p1Brownbeard warns soldiers of Punk Hazard they have been fooled and will be killed if they stay, revealing Caesar's lies with urgent angry intent.
p1Marines react with surprise noting Brownbeard's presence and questioning his statements.
p1Brownbeard insists everything Caesar said is a lie while marines discuss calling him up or heading down.
p2Brownbeard questions the gate closure and calls out his subordinate for being insistent.
p2Caesar Clown demands answers with furious roar.
p2Brownbeard retorts that his men did not die and should have returned.
p3Subordinates report they cannot enter due to marines and closed gate, pleading for orders.
p3Caesar dismisses the problem and notes the island will soon be covered with Shinokuni.
p3Brownbeard reacts with surprise upon seeing his men and Caesar offers false reassurance.
p4Brownbeard shouts in fury that he can no longer trust anything said by the other party.
p4Subordinate cries out in shock questioning how Brownbeard could speak that way to his master.
p4Another subordinate yells asking what happened to Brownbeard.
p4Background minions mutter worriedly about missing allies still on the other side.
p4Dark-haired woman whispers in shock noting that Brownbeard called the other party by name.
p4Brownbeard yells at the group that they must leave the island immediately after two years together.
p5Crowd erupts in loud laughter mocking Brownbeard's unclear speech.
p5Spiky-haired man asks Brownbeard if he did something to him while naming Caesar.
p5Brownbeard struggles with mouth not moving properly while trying to say 'guinea pigs'.
p5Spiky-haired man internally notes that the crowd fails to realize Brownbeard means 'guinea pigs'.
p5Spiky-haired man comments that the subordinates are all idiots.
p6Brownbeard screams that the other party abandoned his men and calls him a rotten bastard.
p6Spiky-haired man whispers about former underlings and recalls a past event from four years ago.
p6Spiky-haired man states that the weapon of mass destruction was his doing.
p6Horrified subordinate reacts with shock to the revelation.
p7Subordinates yell at Brownbeard asking what he is doing and calling for help.
p7Voices accuse the spiky-haired man of orchestrating the island as a living hell.
p7Brownbeard roars incoherently with distorted speech.
p7A voice urges everyone to run away from the demon-like figure.
p8Marine commands FIRE!! with urgent attack intent.
p8Marine yells they are too late and Brownbeard is manipulated by Strawhat in alarm.
p8Marine cries Brownbeard has become quite dangerous in fear.
p8Unknown figure declares SHURORO RORO!! AND NOW FOR THE FINISHER while flicking switch with sinister intent.
p9Marine screams GEGH HH!!! and GYAH HH!!! while hit by tail.
p9Marine shouts MASTER!? in confusion during rampage.
p9Marine gasps GASTA... amid attack.
p9Marine yells IT GRAZED ME!!! SHIT WHO'S THIS NOW!! in shock.
p9Marine cries DAHHHH!! TH-TH... THAT WAS CLOSE!! while panting.
p10Marine shouts IT'S STRAWHAT LUFFY!! in surprise.
p10Marine declares MASTER IS OUR MERCIFUL SAVIOR GOD...!! with gratitude.
p10Wounded marine groans AUU... AUU... in pain.
p11Figure yells ROGER!! and orders broadcaster connected to every region.
p11Figure commands PREPARE FOR THE EXPERIMENT TO COMMENCE!! with urgency.
p11Figure orders GET BACK TO THE SECOND FLOOR MEN!!!.
p11Girl says YOU HAVE TO EAT YOU KNOW... with caring tone.
p11Horned figure notes SO YOU'RE MOMONOSUKE-KUN HUH.
p11Horned figure states THAT'S THE ONE THAT HE IS... with recognition.
p11Spiky-haired man says I KNOW... in response.
p11Horned figure declares NOT ONE WILL BE LEFT ALIVE!! with menacing laugh.
p12Law states everyone here has been tricked in some way, with serious intent.
p12Luffy shouts in shock asking what kind of island this is.
p12Law explains the island is a lot like gas and does not seem to exist.
p12Luffy mutters SHUURO RORORORO in realization while panting heavily.
p13Law declares thanks to a powerful ally it is like none of it ever happened and everything is covered up.
p13Masked voices taunt that no one will come to save them and they can scream or cry.
p13Law reveals Law is trying to get his hands on the S.A.D. and is plotting to kidnap him.
p13Luffy stares in surprise at the unfolding revelations.
p14Man reveals Donquixote Doflamingo has a factory that turns S.A.D. into fruits called SMILE.
p14Man identifies the Shichibukai as the most dangerous man out there.
p14Narration states SMILES are manmade devil fruits holding Zoan powers.
p14Narration notes fruits are sought after by anyone craving power and used in business with New World big names.
p15Voice notes Doflamingo amassed an ability user corps of several hundred members.
p15Voice states one of the Yonkou has already benefited from SMILE.
p15Law warns Luffy will incur the unimaginable wrath of the biggest players.
p15Law panics that Law is aiming for just that and the whole world will respond.
p15Luffy shouts DOFLAMINGO while questioning the scale of the fight.
p16Luffy declares he has always picked fights like this the whole way, conveying fierce determination and defiance.
One Piece Chapter 689: An Island That Seems Not to Exist